文章摘要
周京艳,黄裕荣,刘如,张惠娜. 智能集体评审的缘起和特征. 中国科技期刊研究, 2018, 29(3): 231-236
智能集体评审的缘起和特征
Origin and feature of intelligent crowd review
投稿时间:2017-09-18  修订日期:2018-01-10
DOI:10.11946/cjstp.201709180788
中文关键词: 智能集体评审  开放同行评审  匿名评审
英文关键词: Intelligent crowd review  Open peer review  Anonymous review
摘要点击次数: 443
全文下载次数: 479
基金项目:北京市财政项目
作者单位E-mail
周京艳 北京市科学技术情报研究所北京市西城区西外大街140号 100044 zhouyan-720@163.com 
黄裕荣 北京市科学技术情报研究所北京市西城区西外大街140号 100044  
刘如 北京市科学技术情报研究所北京市西城区西外大街140号 100044  
张惠娜 北京市科学技术情报研究所北京市西城区西外大街140号 100044  
中文摘要:
      【目的】 探索智能集体评审的流程、特征及对我国同行评审的启示。【方法】 介绍智能集体评审实验,概括智能集体评审的特征,分析其对我国学术期刊同行评审的启示。【结果】 智能集体评审是一种限时的在线开放同行评审,采取专家匿名评审方式。评审过程中,评审人之间可进行学术交流。评审意见快速而全面,有利于提高论文的学术质量,是一种可行的同行评审方式。【结论】 作为一种全新的同行评审方式,智能集体评审全面推行尚需时日,但其给当前同行评审以重要启示:一是加快信息技术的应用;二是为评审专家提供交流机会。
英文摘要:
      [Purposes] The purposes of this study are to explore the process and characteristics of intelligent crowd review and the enlightenment to peer review of Chinese scientific journals. [Methods] We introduced the experiment of intelligent crowd review from Prof. Benjamin List, the editor-in-chief of <i>Synlett</i>, summarized the characteristics of intelligent crowd review, and analyzed the enlightenment to improve the peer review of Chinese academic journals. [Findings] Intelligent crowd review is a time-limited online peer review, and it is a type of anonymous review. During the review process, the reviewers can communicate with each other about the academic questions and exchange opinions. The review comments are quick and comprehensive, which is conducive to improving the quality of academic papers, and it is also a feasible way of peer review. [Conclusions] As a new way of peer review, intelligent crowd review gives an important enlightenment to the current peer review, such as speeding up the application of information technology and providing reviewers with the opportunity to communicate with each other.
HTML   查看全文   查看/发表评论  下载PDF阅读器
关闭
微信扫一扫看